I rewatched the original trilogy of Star Wars recently and a nagging question kept popping into my head, "Yeah, but are they evil" every time people alluded to the "evil" Galactic Empire. Sure, the military guys are all English and nobody's pretty-looking, but aside from that, they all seem pretty down-to-earth. Some systems don't agree with the Empire, but hey, that's how government works. You won't even find a government on Earth that is unanimously beloved by its people.
I don't applaud the Emperor's subversive tactics by any means, and Vader isn't much better when it comes to what he does to people who fail him. In the end, it works-- at least for a while-- because it's undeniable, though, that while the Emporer gets his jollies off on power, he's relatively lax on infringements of personal liberty. In Return of the Jedi, the Emperor simply lets Luke come to him as opposed to going planet to planet interrogating people and shit. Instead, he gives Luke the opportunity to have audience with the Emperor and to even have a position on his staff-- so long as he acts like a human as opposed to some holier-art-thou Jedi. Prior to that, when Vader is searching for the rebellion , instead of invading planets and blowing shit up, he simply sends harmless probe droids to see if they can find anything. It's not just the Rebellion, either, because we can clearly see in Empire Strikes Back that the Empire realistically doesn't give a shit about Lando's Cloud City and all of their shenanigans until they start harboring terrorists. In A New Hope, the people who die are Luke's Aunt and Uncle as well as the robot-stealing Jawas; for, the main reason they all are killed is because they could have easily been in possession of stolen droids, or worse: the plans to the Death Star.
This brings up a good point, because I don't know about you, but if I knew that some random, possibly malfunctioning droid was walking around with highly-classified, highly-detailed technical plans that could be used by any joe schmoe to build a nearly invincible planet-destroying monstrosity, I would take every precaution to see to it that those plans were recovered immediately-- no matter what it took. I'd say the equivalent for modern society would be some schizophrenic dude running around with step-by-step instructions to build as many small, cobalt-salted nuclear bombs as anyone could ever want....
Continue reading "Who was more evil: the empire or the rebellion?"